Miiversepedia
35 Posts
TheSwordWillCome
DustyTheFlygon
Mira Laime
TheOrcaApocalypse
Muffet146
All Contributors
Charizard 'M
Technickal
Digit03
Enigminator
Darkwing Duckness
Supereggy5
Neat Lady
+7
This post is locked.

Community Discussion: Should Digit03 be stripped of his bureaucrat status on Miiversepedia?

After sending the previous poll to the Wikia staff member that initially replied to me regarding the complaints about Digit03 (semanticdrifter), I was met with the following reply:

We generally don't remove rights from bureaucrats unless it's clear that there is a community consensus to do so.

We need to see this consensus on the wikia itself.

If you wish to pursue this approach, we suggest you hold a public discussion on your community (open to all community members) asking if the bureaucrat should be demoted. This needs be on a community page, not on chat or another website; and in discussion form, not as a poll. That way, we can see who voted and what they voted for.

Please keep this discussion open for one week, or until all active community members have had an opportunity to voice their opinion. If the result is that the community has decided the bureaucrat should be removed, we can remove the rights.

Thanks!

As such, and corresponding to the overwhelming response I received on the previous poll, I've decided to follow the above message's instructions and create a community discussion. If you have something to say, feel free to say it! I'll make sure that no responses on this thread are removed; every thought is valuable when debating a topic such as this. The discussion will be left open for a week, so that everyone involved will have an opportunity to voice their say here. Thanks!

(In case you didn't read the finish to the previous thread: On this thread we're discussing the removal of bureaucrat rights solely; Digit03's admin rights will remain unless a drastic change in the wiki's structure occurs.)

0 85
  • Upvote
  • Reply
Charizard 'M
Technickal
Digit03
Enigminator
Darkwing Duckness
Supereggy5
Neat Lady
+7
0
Digit03 wrote:
No one's taking this thread seriously.

I am.

0
Digit03 wrote:
No one's taking this thread seriously.

I try to take this thread seriously.

0

Appears that I should have locked this thread a few days ago, as I was requested by Wikia Staff to leave the thread open for a week, and that amount of time has been surpassed at this point.  Therefore, I'd like you, the users of this wiki, to submit your final view on the topic of this thread, whether the user should keep his position on the wiki or not.  If 66% or more users agree the user should be removed from his position, I'll send a response to Wikia Staff within a day of the thread being locked (which should be a day from the moment this message is sent)

0
Keep his position. He always followed the guidelines.
0
Am I allowed to have a say in the vote?
0
My vote is for him to stay.
0

To keep this vote "fair," is it okay if only administrators or people with over 50 edits are allowed to vote? That way, random users who never edit here won't come on and just vote against me simply because they don't like me.

1
Digit03 wrote:
To keep this vote "fair," is it okay if only administrators or people with over 50 edits are allowed to vote? That way, random users who never edit here won't come on and just vote against me simply because they don't like me.

Yes

0
I agree with that as well.
0

Okay then, seems it's decided:

Digit03 will keep his position as bureaucrat of Miiversepedia for the present moment.

Thanks to everyone who came out here and posted their thoughts, it's nice to hear others' opinions.

I'm going to lock this, since it doesn't serve much of a purpose now.  If you have any further questions or thoughts, feel free to post them on my message wall.